Sunlight filtered into the bedroom, illuminating the still form of a young woman in bed. Beside her, Steven sat in a chair, his gaze fixed on her. Waiting.
He’d been doing this for weeks—waiting for her to wake, waiting for her to speak, waiting for any sign that the girl he knew was still in there.
A soft groan escaped her lips as she stirred. Ruthie rubbed the sleep from one eye, her voice thick and groggy.
“Mmmm. Why do you watch me like that?” she murmured, meeting his gaze. “Are you only attracted to me when I’m defenseless?”
“Good morning, Ruthie,” he said, his voice a carefully constructed wall of calm. “How did you sleep?”
“I don’t remember waking up in the middle of the night, so I guess I slept all right.”
“You don’t remember?”
“What?”
“Yelling at me,” he said.
Ruthie’s brow furrowed, a flicker of defiance sparking in her eyes.
“Did you deserve it?”
“You mean, did I try to touch you? No.”
She sighed, resigned. “So, what did I say?”
“A lot of things.”
“Like?”
He hesitated. “You talked about… her.”
Ruthie’s expression hardened. “She has a name, you know.”
“Why do I need to say it? You know who I mean.”
“Say her name,” she insisted, voice sharp and low.
He exhaled. Tired. Cornered. “Aisha. Satisfied?”
“Never,” she replied instantly. Then, after a pause: “So what did I say?”
“You blamed me. For what happened to her.”
“I see,” Ruthie said, her face unreadable.
“Do you?” he pressed. “Do you blame me?”
She turned the question back on him, a familiar tactic.
“Does it bother you? Me blaming you?”
He ignored the deflection. “You still love her, don’t you?”
“No,” she said, too quickly.
“Don’t lie to me, Ruthie.”
“And if I do?” she challenged.
Steven’s tone grew heavy—part pity, part accusation.
“That poor girl had no idea what she was getting into with you. You were a storm she couldn’t see coming.”
An ironic chuckle escaped Ruthie’s lips. “I’m the best at what I do.”
“If you really loved her,” he said, his voice cracking slightly, “you should have let her go. The way I told you to.”
A soft sliding sound broke the silence. The closet door on the far side of the room glided open.
Another young woman—Aisha—was hanging upside down from the clothing bar, suspended by her ankles, her long hair brushing the floor.
“Why do you do that?” Aisha asked, her voice calm despite her position.
“Morning, Aisha,” Ruthie said, unfazed.
“Morning. Why do you taunt him?”
“Because he needs to pay,” Ruthie answered, her eyes still on Steven, who saw nothing but an open closet door. “But he never will.”
“Stranger things have happened.”
“But not to men like him.”
Aisha considered this. “You’re being too hard on him.”
“Hard on him?” Ruthie scoffed, finally looking away.
“Yes. He’s going through a tough time.”
“How is this about him?”
“Because he’s the one who’ll have to live with your decision.”
“Let’s get one thing straight,” Ruthie said, sitting up fully, her voice like steel. “This is my life. Not his. He doesn’t own me.”
“Ruthie, what you’re planning to do is wrong.”
“Why?” Ruthie demanded. “If I decide I don’t want to live anymore, that’s my choice. Who has the right to demand I keep suffering? What kind of life is it, if I don’t get to choose it?”
“I want what’s best for you,” Aisha said gently. “I always have.”
“Then tell me what’s wrong with ending it.”
“Because you’re planning to do it here. In his house,” Aisha said, each word sharp as a razor. “Because it’s not just about ending your pain. It’s about adding to his.”
“Get out,” Ruthie whispered.
With practiced grace, Aisha unhooked herself, landing lightly. She stretched, walked to the bedroom door, and passed through it like smoke.
In the bright, clean kitchen, Steven juggled breakfast and his own thoughts. He divided a skillet of scrambled eggs onto two plates and set them on the table. Reaching for a mug, he froze. It was Aisha’s favorite. He pushed it behind the coffee maker.
Ruthie entered and plopped into a chair. Aisha was already there, perched on the counter. Steven walked right through her, making her flicker for a second.
He sat across from Ruthie.
“You never came to bed last night,” he said, nudging a plate toward her.
She stared at the eggs in silence. She remembered making them for Aisha, who always stole bacon off her plate. The memory hit like a punch.
“Were you up all night?” Steven asked.
“This day just keeps getting worse,” Aisha muttered from the counter.
Ruthie looked at him. “Why did you tell me to leave her alone?”
The question caught him off guard. “What?”
“Back then. You said I’d ruin her. You said to stay away.”
Steven put his fork down. “You were twenty. She was seventeen. You were… reckless. I was worried.”
“You were jealous,” Ruthie snapped. “You wanted her for yourself.”
“That’s not true,” he said, but his eyes darted away.
“Isn’t it?” Aisha said, now sitting in the chair beside Ruthie, her eyes locked on Steven. “You used to watch me too. When you thought no one was looking.”
Ruthie flinched like she’d heard it aloud. “She told me, you know. Said you gave her the creeps sometimes.”
Color drained from Steven’s face. “She never said that.”
“She said you looked at her like… something to own. Like a regret you wanted to fix. You’re her father, Steven. Her father.”
“I was trying to protect her!” he exploded, his composure fracturing. “From you! From your world! I knew you’d drag her down into the same hell you live in—and I was right!”
The plates rattled. His outburst lingered, raw and ugly.
“I was the only good thing in her life,” Ruthie said softly. “And you took her away. Convinced her I was poison. You sent her on that trip to ‘clear her head’…”
Her voice cracked. The hiking trip. The one he paid for. The one Aisha never came back from. The fall police called a tragic accident.
“You’re right,” Steven whispered. “I did. I thought… I thought I was saving her.”
“She’s right here, you know.” Ruthie gave him a strange, calm smile and gestured to the empty chair. “She wants to know if you’re sorry.”
Steven stared at the space beside her, his face contorting with grief and horror. He was looking at the ghost of his daughter—filtered through the madness of the woman who loved her.
“I’m sorry for all of it,” he choked out, speaking to the air. “Aisha… I am so sorry.”
Aisha, visible only to Ruthie, looked not at her father, but at her. She reached out and laid a phantom hand over Ruthie’s. It was cold—like a deep memory.
“He’s paid enough,” Aisha whispered. “And so have you.”
Ruthie looked down at her hand. Then up at Steven, weeping across the table. For the first time in months, the burning need for revenge in her chest flickered. Not extinguished—but no longer the only thing keeping her warm.
“See you at breakfast,” Aisha said, offering a small, sad smile before fading completely—leaving only the scent of lavender and the heavy silence of two broken people at a table set for three.